如何看待川大统领表示掌握武汉肺炎来源于实验室的证据?

https://twitter.com/NBCNewsWorld/status/1255991607473721345?s=19

看来cia没吃白饭
en010272 黑名单 自由国度一漂萍
President Trump suggests he has seen evidence that the coronavirus was created in a Wuhan lab, hours after the DNI said in a statement that the virus was "not manmade or genetically modified."
还是静观其变吧

国务卿蓬佩奥作为上一任中情局局长,如果能展现出点真本事,那倒也是好的
如果是川普以外任何一个大国领导人说的,那绝对是今年第一爆炸性新闻,可以占据所有媒体头版头条。
但既然是川普说的,那还得再等两天看看美国朝野的反应。
明泽殿下的粉丝 發發牢騷,一派胡言,不反對黨和國家,不反對一尊,網警饒命
On川普大統領的確喜歡胡說八道。
之前他還說他已經知道了金正恩的狀態,但是又不能告訴大家。還說很快就會公佈消息,結果等了這麼久也沒有公佈。
明顯就是帶一波節奏而已。

感覺病毒是人造的,這個可能性並不是很大。
川大统领就是个纯智障,我现在认为他和习包子关系好一定是真的,两个250真能有一块儿去
日常放狠話,很有個性的一個總統,僅供參考     紫薯紫薯
品姜品蒜 已移民,目前在美国和欧盟两地生活。
CNN 已经在打脸了,呵呵。当然,你也可以说 CNN 是假新闻。

《特朗普声称已看到冠状病毒起源于中国实验室的证据的说法与美国情报界相抵触》

Trump contradicts US intel community by claiming he's seen evidence coronavirus originated in Chinese lab

https://www.cnn.com/2020/04/30/politics/trump-intelligence-community-china-coronavirus-origins/index.html
CNNの两个凡是:
凡是川普支持的我们就反对。
凡是拜登做错的我们就装瞎。

川普明面上说习近平是我的好朋友,实际上对维尼的屁股疯狂的输出。
CNN明面上说川普居然想和独裁者做好朋友,实际上疯狂地舔维尼的屁眼。
WhosYourDaddy Fight for Freedom! Hold on HK! Hold on TW!
應該是另一套直屬總統的情報系統提供的證據,FBI 和 CIA 都有 Deep state,不會好好去調查,反而阻撓調查。

個人猜測,應該和前幾天出逃歐洲的 P4 實驗室研究員有關,這個研究員已經到達美國。
KimmyGray 小熊维尼
NBC News bias is Lean Left. 
CNN 更是左派媒体

观察美国政治,很重要的一点是,反对派的媒体一直在曲解总统的意思。奥巴马时期的官方消息看CNN,现在是共和党执政,官方消息要看右派媒体 Fox News。

很多刚翻墙出来的国人,以为看了CNN、CNBC、NBC、华盛顿邮报、Bloomberg,就能了解美国的主流声音,其实只是少数反对派的声音

信息自由的目的是获得信息平衡、兼听则明。中文媒体大多亲北京,所以需要看英文右派媒体,才能平衡。这也是看品葱的意义所在。

现在最想把川普拉下马的,一是民主党,二是北京。所以从某种意义上讲,美国民主党和中国共产党在同一条战壕里,CNN 和 CCTV大外宣虽然手段不同,但是目标相同。

首先,Fox News 和一众反共自媒体都没有报道这一则消息,如果川普真的表示掌握病毒来自武汉实验室的证据,这样大一个瓜,为何不报?

我们来看一下完整版的视频,题主的视频是两段对话拼接而成的
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_6KwBOyhybg

第一段从54:40开始:( ... 表示被打断)

John: You said a moment ago you will soon have information on where this virus originated. The director of National Intelligence today put out a statement saying that they believe it was naturally occurring that was not man-made...

Trump: Who is that? Who said ...

John: The office of the Director of National Intelligence. 

Trump: In particular who was the man that made this way? 

John: That was a statement ... 

Trump: We would know that. OK. We will see. 

John: That was your National Intelligence ...

Trump: Well, right now I think, I think it's, I mean you have to tell me who specifically who made this statement?

John: The statement was just put out under the office of ... 

Trump: I haven't seen the statement. 

John: The question I had was have you seen at this point ...

Trump: We are looking at, John, separately ... We are looking at it exactly where it came from, who it came from, how it happened, separately and also scientifically. We are going to be able to find it. 

John: My question is: have you seen anything at this point that gives you a high degree of confidence that the Wuhan Institute of biology was the origin of this virus? 

Trump: Yes, I have. Yes, I have. And I think the World Health Organization should be ashamed of themselves. Because they are like the public relations agency for China. And this country pays them almost 500 million dollars a year and China pays them 38 million dollars a year, and whether it's a lot or more it doesn't matter it's still they shouldn't be making excuses when people make horrible mistakes, especially mistakes that are causing hundreds of thousands of people around the world to die. I think the World Health Organization should be ashamed of themselves. 

第二段从1:00:35开始:

Trump: Yes, please. 

John: We were talking about just a second ago I missed in the interruption. Did you, are you suggesting that maybe you have some evidence that this was not a naturally occurring virus?

Trump: We are gonna see ... what are you talking about the virus and ... 

John: right ...

Trump:  ... where it came from?

John: ... yeah 

Trump: We are gonna see what it is. We are gonna see where it comes from. And you know, look, you've known every theory that you had the theory from the lab, you had the theory from many different the bats, you know the type of bat, and the bat is 40 miles away, so it could have been here, it could have been there, etc. And we have, there's a lot of theories but, yeah, we have people looking at it very very strongly. Scientific people, intelligence people and others. ... and ... and put it all together ... China might even tell us ... China may tell us. 

John: ... and ... and what gives you high degree of confidence that this originated from the Wuhan Institute of virology?

Trump: I can't tell you, I am not allowed to tell you that. 

从这两段对话来看,
第一:川普并没有声称 “掌握武汉肺炎来源于实验室的证据”,所以不存在 evidence
第二:这个是记者一再诱导追问,而不是川普主动提出的观点,所以不存在 suggest
第三:原话是“originated from”,未必是人造,有可能是泄露,所以不存在 created

NBC News 的标题是:
President Trump suggests he has seen evidence that the coronavirus was created in a Wuhan lab, hours after the DNI said in a statement that the virus was "not manmade or genetically modified."

再来回顾第一段对话中John的问题:
John: My question is: have you seen anything at this point that gives you a high degree of confidence that the Wuhan Institute of biology was the origin of this virus? 

翻译:到目前为止,你有没有曾经看到过任何一个东西,可以给你高度自信,认为武汉病毒研究所是这个病毒的来源?

为什么我们会怀疑武汉病毒研究所?因为我们每个怀疑的人,都曾经看到过让我们相信可能来自于武汉病毒研究所的信息。如果我们不曾看到任何一个这样的信息,就不会怀疑。

怀疑不等于确定,出现了让我们怀疑(甚至产生高度自信)的东西,并不等于拥有了证据。

比如我听了一个故事、发现一段艾滋病的基因片段、发现治埃博拉的药也可以治新冠,这些都可以给我高度自信,认为病毒是人工合成的,或者来自武汉P4。但是要验证这些信息,需要专业人士,这些信息成为证据还有很长的路要走。

所以在第一段对话里,川普说许多科学家、情报人员在努力工作,寻求真相。

第二段对话里,记者又问了同样的问题。川普回答说“这是你的理论,你们知道很多理论,包括来自武汉lab、来自蝙蝠,蝙蝠距离lab有40英里,所以它也可能来自这儿,也可能来自那儿”。最后记者问川普“是什么东西给了你高度自信?” 川普说,我不能告诉你,我不被允许告诉你。

为什么不能告诉?因为那些东西还有待验证,还不是证据。而验证的过程需要保密。


从这个例子可以看出,左派媒体是如何曲解川普的:
[NBC News] President Trump suggests he has seen evidence that the coronavirus was created in a Wuhan lab. 

suggests, evidence, created 这三个词都是无中生有、误导观众的。
Emmanuels 韭病成医
川普现在放这个话出来看TG的反应。一来为继续贸易战作铺垫,二来为美国100多万确诊,6万多死亡找个泄愤口。大概率是TG急妥协,派刘鹤谈判,把人家要求赔偿的钱,以多缴关税等贸易方式,变相赔偿给美国,只是大家都不说破。对于TG来说,美国一旦安抚,其他屁国即无关紧要。继续安心狂割韭菜赔偿美国的同时,墙内散播美帝的邪恶。对TG来说,两全齐美。可怜的是墙民,亢奋的生长为TG的恶去赔偿美帝,然后还誓死捍卫TG的执政合法性。蠢到无可救药。
sanjo 千年盐碱地上唯一盛开的不屈之花
日,这标题我刚开始读成:川大  统领。还纳闷谁这么厉害能做四川大学的统领,还能知道有关P4的信息。

要发言请先登录注册

发起人

Deatholder 黑名单

人在大陆,巴不得明天共匪就死

状态

  • 最新活动: 2020-05-02
  • 浏览: 8039