[imdb list] 在豆瓣消失匿迹的电影列表 适合反贼看的电影推荐

douban vanishing: https://www.imdb.com/list/ls066081960/?ref_=tt_rls_3

电影返校最近被列入了豆瓣的黑名单,在imdb查找返校的时候发现了一个名为douban vanishing(消失在豆瓣)这个电影列表,原来已经有人整理出了这样的列表,是个好东西,于是决定分享出来。

https://i.imgur.com/LEte9vS.png
前两部是同属于China in Revolution一个系列的,总共有3部,Part One: China in Revolution 1911-1949 (1989), Part Two: The Mao Years 1949-1976 (1994) and Part Three: Born Under the Red Flag 1976-1997 (1997),只有第一部没有被豆瓣屏蔽,这两部搜英文名字,youtube上有。

注意,第二部说毛腊肉的有洗白腊肉嫌疑,尽管如此,依然被禁了。

以下引用imdb第二部影评:

While the facts are essentially correct, the film seemed incredibly nonchalant about widespread murder.

When I looked up "China in Revolution" on IMDb, I didn't find it. After a bit of digging, I realized that originally this was shown as three separate shows over many years. The DVD set "China in Revolution" consists of: Part One: China in Revolution 1911-1949 (1989), Part Two: The Mao Years 1949-1976 (1994) and Part Three: Born Under the Red Flag 1976-1997 (1997). This review is for Part Two.

Not surprisingly, this installment of the China trilogy begins just after the Communists gained control of the Chinese mainland and ends with the death of Mao. The film, while quite factual and well constructed, was a disappointment. While Part One was critical of the Nationalist government (and rightfully so as they seemed to have no regard for the peasants), Part Two seemed, at times, amazingly non-committal about the murders of many millions of Chinese by the new regime. Twice during the film actual numbers of killed were mentioned (100,000 landlords killed just after the revolution and about 400,000 during the Cultural Revolution), but otherwise the film was amazingly silent. Considering the LOW estimates of the numbers executed or starved to death during Mao's reign are in the low millions and high estimates top 70,000,000, doesn't the films not mentioning this seem wrong?! It would be like a documentary about Hitler mentioning the murder of Gypsies, homosexuals and political prisoners--but no mention of the 6,000,000 Jews! This show really makes me wonder what was going on behind the scenes with this film. Did the filmmakers deliberately fail to mention the huge atrocities so that they could gain the cooperation of the present administration? Or, did they have some other agenda? All I know is that although the film appeared well made, the film was basically dishonest--making the deaths that occurred seem only to be the responsibility of some radical peasants taking it upon themselves to execute some 'enemies of the state'.

Overall, a film that seemed to try hard NOT to criticize Mao. Why? I have no idea. But let's not have a whitewash here--he was an incredibly evil man.


https://i.imgur.com/7rdKRmD.png https://i.imgur.com/XA2JQ60.png https://i.imgur.com/5CU8dxx.png https://i.imgur.com/FGu7AQq.png https://i.imgur.com/gwsDuQx.png https://i.imgur.com/YbWzYUO.png https://i.imgur.com/JdffYsY.png https://i.imgur.com/VtTF43C.png https://i.imgur.com/VbTkAgZ.png https://i.imgur.com/iMY8BQa.png https://i.imgur.com/SkXMqvg.png https://i.imgur.com/X2uTfWO.png https://i.imgur.com/KGL6nyU.png https://i.imgur.com/Pq5Ynka.png https://i.imgur.com/rB0uet8.png
26
分享 2020-02-05

21 个评论

有的豆列也很厉害

https://www.douban.com/doulist/988515/ 抗争与社会运动1
https://www.douban.com/doulist/1820245/ 抗争与社会运动2
「中国:革命的世纪」好是好,只是第一集和后两集画风根本180度翻转。第一集定稿时尚未发生八九民运,内容极度舔共,第二集和第三集是在八九后完稿的,因此画风一转为360度全方位花式辱共。何前卑而后倨也?私以为这反应了西方自由派认识中共上存在的一种肤浅性
沒有藍宇嗎,我以為這部也被禁,當時能拍出來也是很不可思議
北京故事小说改编?

對啊,這東西放在現在應該不可能拍出來吧
「中国:革命的世纪」好是好,只是第一集和后两集画风根本180度翻转。第一集定稿时尚未发生八九民运,内...

说肤浅的,你对共产主义运动的历史认识还不是很清楚。推荐看唐顿庄园前几季
KANO是真的不错
弱弱的问一下 资源去哪找
豆瓣里好像有很多反共越战片都没被禁掉,像现代启示录、野战排、生于七月四日这些,有关苏联题材就更多了,连近年拿奥斯卡的水形物语都是有关冷战背景的,不过这些片真的拍得挺好看的。
mark一下
没看过,台湾人去日本,怎么成禁片了

反了,二战时期日本人去日占台湾教一群学生打棒球的故事,因为在作品里说了日本人在台湾建水坝被共青团点名媚日封了。
昂山素季现在和中共的关系这么好,也许the lady不久后会在国内解禁。

《颐和园》其实和政治没有关系,虽然有六四的片段,但是更多的是一个爱情片。
采访居然也被禁了
韩影还有一部被禁的《安市城》 看完一头雾水到底有什么可禁的 因为打破了脆弱的民族自豪感?
讓子彈飛原來沒被禁,我一直以為它早被禁了說
有的豆列也很厉害https://www.douban.com/doulist/988515/ 抗争与...

好像都没了
樓主之前推的頻道不錯看來表揚一下XD
順便如果沒辦法去台灣看返校的話還有什麼途徑可以看到正版嗎
看過第9部 The Ditch,中文翻譯過來就是「夾邊溝」,從書改的,講勞改時期。

整個片子很壓抑 也有點無聊 因為過於寫實 感覺都不像一部電影。一群人被送到夾邊溝 完全沒有生活保障,中間發生了什麼我不太記得 反正後來就一直在死人 死到影片裡其他角色和作為觀眾的我都麻木了。

讓我印象比較深刻的一個片段是有個人不知道吃了什麼吃壞肚子吐了,然後另一個人看到之後直接去吃他的嘔吐物。那時候真的就慘到這種地步,人吃人的事情也是在這會兒發生的。
少了三部:
獨生之國、洗鈔事務所和我們的青春在台灣

我在Matters寫了3部「豆瓣沒有的電影」
(但我後來發現樹大招風其實有)

短网址/39c1z6a ← 這是洗鈔的短評
短网址/37273yG ← 這是我們的青春的短評
(有時間會繼續寫 史達林死了沒和獨生之國的介紹)
这个list太好了,建议置顶,品葱或许也可以开个书影音专区,推荐一些禁书禁片禁歌等等
我找了找 在imdb上好像是叫Movies I do not see but 404 in douban?
Missing a few!!

The Gate of Heavenly Peace - AKA 天安门
https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0115005/?ref_=nv_sr_srsg_1_tt_5_nm_3_q_xiuxiu

Xiu Xiu the sent down girl - 天浴

要发言请先登录注册

要发言请先登录注册