论美国的大一统和中共的反大一统
先说一下大一统的定义:
https://zh.wikipedia.org/wiki/%E5%A4%A7%E4%B8%80%E7%BB%9F
大一统是中國自西周以来的一種尊崇各種制度统一的立國观念,例如历法统一、政令统一、國家統一、民族统一、思想统一、禮儀统一、度量衡统一、文字統一都屬於尊崇一统的大一統範疇。《公羊传》就曾經提到「大一统」這一觀念。
今天下,车同轨,书同文,行同伦。——《礼记中庸篇第28》
也就是说大一统指的是是一套规则的统一,而和极权扯不上任何关系,不会有人觉得封建制的西周是极权的吧?
按照西周的标准,美国是大一统的国家吗?
美国的历法统一。
政令统一:美国宪法明确了由选举产生的政府具有唯一的合法性。
国家统一:同上。
民族统一:美利坚民族。
https://www.amazon.sg/American-Nation-History-United-Central/dp/1256079332/ref=sr_1_3?crid=2KR3U50A6TBAA&dib=eyJ2IjoiMSJ9.1fFvRm0Gg73Qiic9QVqiYpWgImkRXUtugOlGBMWKlBD761lCxgkM0ew8s6Fh5FpyaP2fXvImh6aeVzw_tcS4dccRyKv4ktAfLxQJc9uMYYr7F-aV9vJNJ4paTYOyhTZiIBz79E7ORjf5KCe2ZIXIu0FTmj-PTZP4JXNchu9rlTgDsWm4wnWZjwoS8AL-6nJaPlkSyTQn1XnxtgJHis2Hlkbrd9SAblMmAVyB_sevfd2elIjUHVQAtF4dh0OHTnXskk5qubzgyLp2PZ_TqiM4GxcUDm59BkbxSKoWC7cr1Jk.005WEwcLdreYDRKgoLnpXExD69HvJOfLqkPJtrGlMX4&dib_tag=se&keywords=American+Nation&qid=1711160940&sprefix=american+nation%2Caps%2C385&sr=8-3
The American Nation: A History of the United Sates (Central Texas Edition)
https://www.amazon.sg/American-Nation-Causes-Civil-1859-1861/dp/1020467134/ref=sr_1_4?crid=2KR3U50A6TBAA&dib=eyJ2IjoiMSJ9.1fFvRm0Gg73Qiic9QVqiYpWgImkRXUtugOlGBMWKlBD761lCxgkM0ew8s6Fh5FpyaP2fXvImh6aeVzw_tcS4dccRyKv4ktAfLxQJc9uMYYr7F-aV9vJNJ4paTYOyhTZiIBz79E7ORjf5KCe2ZIXIu0FTmj-PTZP4JXNchu9rlTgDsWm4wnWZjwoS8AL-6nJaPlkSyTQn1XnxtgJHis2Hlkbrd9SAblMmAVyB_sevfd2elIjUHVQAtF4dh0OHTnXskk5qubzgyLp2PZ_TqiM4GxcUDm59BkbxSKoWC7cr1Jk.005WEwcLdreYDRKgoLnpXExD69HvJOfLqkPJtrGlMX4&dib_tag=se&keywords=American+Nation&qid=1711160940&sprefix=american+nation%2Caps%2C385&sr=8-4
The American Nation: Causes Of The Civil War, 1859-1861
https://www.amazon.sg/American-Nation-Beginnings-Through-1877/dp/0130588482/ref=sr_1_12?crid=2KR3U50A6TBAA&dib=eyJ2IjoiMSJ9.1fFvRm0Gg73Qiic9QVqiYpWgImkRXUtugOlGBMWKlBD761lCxgkM0ew8s6Fh5FpyaP2fXvImh6aeVzw_tcS4dccRyKv4ktAfLxQJc9uMYYr7F-aV9vJNJ4paTYOyhTZiIBz79E7ORjf5KCe2ZIXIu0FTmj-PTZP4JXNchu9rlTgDsWm4wnWZjwoS8AL-6nJaPlkSyTQn1XnxtgJHis2Hlkbrd9SAblMmAVyB_sevfd2elIjUHVQAtF4dh0OHTnXskk5qubzgyLp2PZ_TqiM4GxcUDm59BkbxSKoWC7cr1Jk.005WEwcLdreYDRKgoLnpXExD69HvJOfLqkPJtrGlMX4&dib_tag=se&keywords=American+Nation&qid=1711160940&sprefix=american+nation%2Caps%2C385&sr=8-12
The American Nation: Beginnings Through 1877
思想统一:民主制度。
度量衡统一:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_customary_units
Executive Order 12770, signed by President George H. W. Bush on July 25, 1991, citing the Metric Conversion Act, directed departments and agencies within the executive branch of the United States Government to "take all appropriate measures within their authority" to use the metric system "as the preferred system of weights and measures for United States trade and commerce" and authorized the Secretary of Commerce "to charter an Interagency Council on Metric Policy ('ICMP'), which will assist the Secretary in coordinating Federal Government-wide implementation of this order."
文字统一:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Languages_of_the_United_States
The United States does not have an official language at the federal level, but the most commonly used language is English (specifically, American English), which is the de facto national language.
In addition, 32 U.S. states out of 50 and all five U.S. territories have declared English as an official language.
大一统的文字不一定是官方规定的。西周的书同文是金文和大篆,秦是小篆,两汉之后自然而然的演化成了隶书。
而且美国的确有三十个州规定了英语是官方语言。
所以,美国就是个大一统的国家,只不过西周是大一统的封建制国家,美国是大一统的民主制国家。
那为什么中共又是个反大一统的国家呢?
中共给少数民族两少一宽强制汉族一胎,就任官职和居住酒店方面又对少数民族有限制,这明显是分而治之,强制划分不同身份的手段,而且体现了中共了本质上对少数民族和汉族都完全没有认同感,和大一统完全是背道而驰。
如果是大一统的国家,那少数民族不会有两少一宽,也不会强制汉族一胎,新疆人住酒店也不会有额外的检查,这才叫大一统。
https://zh.wikipedia.org/wiki/%E5%A4%A7%E4%B8%80%E7%BB%9F
大一统是中國自西周以来的一種尊崇各種制度统一的立國观念,例如历法统一、政令统一、國家統一、民族统一、思想统一、禮儀统一、度量衡统一、文字統一都屬於尊崇一统的大一統範疇。《公羊传》就曾經提到「大一统」這一觀念。
今天下,车同轨,书同文,行同伦。——《礼记中庸篇第28》
也就是说大一统指的是是一套规则的统一,而和极权扯不上任何关系,不会有人觉得封建制的西周是极权的吧?
按照西周的标准,美国是大一统的国家吗?
美国的历法统一。
政令统一:美国宪法明确了由选举产生的政府具有唯一的合法性。
国家统一:同上。
民族统一:美利坚民族。
https://www.amazon.sg/American-Nation-History-United-Central/dp/1256079332/ref=sr_1_3?crid=2KR3U50A6TBAA&dib=eyJ2IjoiMSJ9.1fFvRm0Gg73Qiic9QVqiYpWgImkRXUtugOlGBMWKlBD761lCxgkM0ew8s6Fh5FpyaP2fXvImh6aeVzw_tcS4dccRyKv4ktAfLxQJc9uMYYr7F-aV9vJNJ4paTYOyhTZiIBz79E7ORjf5KCe2ZIXIu0FTmj-PTZP4JXNchu9rlTgDsWm4wnWZjwoS8AL-6nJaPlkSyTQn1XnxtgJHis2Hlkbrd9SAblMmAVyB_sevfd2elIjUHVQAtF4dh0OHTnXskk5qubzgyLp2PZ_TqiM4GxcUDm59BkbxSKoWC7cr1Jk.005WEwcLdreYDRKgoLnpXExD69HvJOfLqkPJtrGlMX4&dib_tag=se&keywords=American+Nation&qid=1711160940&sprefix=american+nation%2Caps%2C385&sr=8-3
The American Nation: A History of the United Sates (Central Texas Edition)
https://www.amazon.sg/American-Nation-Causes-Civil-1859-1861/dp/1020467134/ref=sr_1_4?crid=2KR3U50A6TBAA&dib=eyJ2IjoiMSJ9.1fFvRm0Gg73Qiic9QVqiYpWgImkRXUtugOlGBMWKlBD761lCxgkM0ew8s6Fh5FpyaP2fXvImh6aeVzw_tcS4dccRyKv4ktAfLxQJc9uMYYr7F-aV9vJNJ4paTYOyhTZiIBz79E7ORjf5KCe2ZIXIu0FTmj-PTZP4JXNchu9rlTgDsWm4wnWZjwoS8AL-6nJaPlkSyTQn1XnxtgJHis2Hlkbrd9SAblMmAVyB_sevfd2elIjUHVQAtF4dh0OHTnXskk5qubzgyLp2PZ_TqiM4GxcUDm59BkbxSKoWC7cr1Jk.005WEwcLdreYDRKgoLnpXExD69HvJOfLqkPJtrGlMX4&dib_tag=se&keywords=American+Nation&qid=1711160940&sprefix=american+nation%2Caps%2C385&sr=8-4
The American Nation: Causes Of The Civil War, 1859-1861
https://www.amazon.sg/American-Nation-Beginnings-Through-1877/dp/0130588482/ref=sr_1_12?crid=2KR3U50A6TBAA&dib=eyJ2IjoiMSJ9.1fFvRm0Gg73Qiic9QVqiYpWgImkRXUtugOlGBMWKlBD761lCxgkM0ew8s6Fh5FpyaP2fXvImh6aeVzw_tcS4dccRyKv4ktAfLxQJc9uMYYr7F-aV9vJNJ4paTYOyhTZiIBz79E7ORjf5KCe2ZIXIu0FTmj-PTZP4JXNchu9rlTgDsWm4wnWZjwoS8AL-6nJaPlkSyTQn1XnxtgJHis2Hlkbrd9SAblMmAVyB_sevfd2elIjUHVQAtF4dh0OHTnXskk5qubzgyLp2PZ_TqiM4GxcUDm59BkbxSKoWC7cr1Jk.005WEwcLdreYDRKgoLnpXExD69HvJOfLqkPJtrGlMX4&dib_tag=se&keywords=American+Nation&qid=1711160940&sprefix=american+nation%2Caps%2C385&sr=8-12
The American Nation: Beginnings Through 1877
思想统一:民主制度。
度量衡统一:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_customary_units
Executive Order 12770, signed by President George H. W. Bush on July 25, 1991, citing the Metric Conversion Act, directed departments and agencies within the executive branch of the United States Government to "take all appropriate measures within their authority" to use the metric system "as the preferred system of weights and measures for United States trade and commerce" and authorized the Secretary of Commerce "to charter an Interagency Council on Metric Policy ('ICMP'), which will assist the Secretary in coordinating Federal Government-wide implementation of this order."
文字统一:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Languages_of_the_United_States
The United States does not have an official language at the federal level, but the most commonly used language is English (specifically, American English), which is the de facto national language.
In addition, 32 U.S. states out of 50 and all five U.S. territories have declared English as an official language.
大一统的文字不一定是官方规定的。西周的书同文是金文和大篆,秦是小篆,两汉之后自然而然的演化成了隶书。
而且美国的确有三十个州规定了英语是官方语言。
所以,美国就是个大一统的国家,只不过西周是大一统的封建制国家,美国是大一统的民主制国家。
那为什么中共又是个反大一统的国家呢?
中共给少数民族两少一宽强制汉族一胎,就任官职和居住酒店方面又对少数民族有限制,这明显是分而治之,强制划分不同身份的手段,而且体现了中共了本质上对少数民族和汉族都完全没有认同感,和大一统完全是背道而驰。
如果是大一统的国家,那少数民族不会有两少一宽,也不会强制汉族一胎,新疆人住酒店也不会有额外的检查,这才叫大一统。
50 个评论
首先要说明,简中键政圈所反对的“大一统”并不是单纯指某种东西被官方规划为标准和领土统一,这个视频说的比较清楚了:https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=rKhnbKy0414&pp=ygUJ5aSn5LiA57uf
先射箭后画靶又不是啥很难的东西,你都首先说美国是大一统然后找特征,那我也可以说中国是“民主国家”嘛
114514论证之美国政治vs中国政治
1:美国有一个语言广泛流行,中国也有一个语言广泛流行
2:美国领土庞大,中国也领土庞大
3:美国没法彻底推翻政党,只能共和民主两党轮流转,中国也没法彻底推翻政党,只能毛左邓右两派轮流转
4:美国很难分裂,中国也很难分裂
5:美国自称民主制,有个president,中国也自称民主制,有个president
6:美国出现过针对学生和退伍兵的镇压,中国也出现过针对退伍老兵和学生的镇压
7:美国抢夺大量印第安人土地,中国也抢夺大量维吾尔人土地
8:美国以前搞过集中营,中国也搞过集中营
9:美国不该歧视人口占12%左右的黑人,中国不准歧视人口只占10%左右的共族人
10:美国有大量报复社会案件,中国也有大量报复社会案件
11:美国打过南北统一战争,中国打过北伐和国共统一战争
结论:通过对比,所以美国和中国没太大区别,都是搞大一统和政党长期垄断,镇压人民,社会矛盾严重激化的国家,太可怕了
先射箭后画靶又不是啥很难的东西,你都首先说美国是大一统然后找特征,那我也可以说中国是“民主国家”嘛
114514论证之美国政治vs中国政治
1:美国有一个语言广泛流行,中国也有一个语言广泛流行
2:美国领土庞大,中国也领土庞大
3:美国没法彻底推翻政党,只能共和民主两党轮流转,中国也没法彻底推翻政党,只能毛左邓右两派轮流转
4:美国很难分裂,中国也很难分裂
5:美国自称民主制,有个president,中国也自称民主制,有个president
6:美国出现过针对学生和退伍兵的镇压,中国也出现过针对退伍老兵和学生的镇压
7:美国抢夺大量印第安人土地,中国也抢夺大量维吾尔人土地
8:美国以前搞过集中营,中国也搞过集中营
9:美国不该歧视人口占12%左右的黑人,中国不准歧视人口只占10%左右的共族人
10:美国有大量报复社会案件,中国也有大量报复社会案件
11:美国打过南北统一战争,中国打过北伐和国共统一战争
结论:通过对比,所以美国和中国没太大区别,都是搞大一统和政党长期垄断,镇压人民,社会矛盾严重激化的国家,太可怕了