Genzo与天下无贼辩论技术的探讨帖

>>请问能解释一下，为什么他向开放式概念要求精准定义时，进入了该谬误吗？

要求精確定義，就是要求要對該概念進行劃界。
一個開放式概念就是不會這樣劃界。


A common first response to the paradox is to term any set of grains that has more than a certain number of grains in it a heap. If one were to define the "fixed boundary" at 10,000 grains then one would claim that for fewer than 10,000, it is not a heap; for 10,000 or more, then it is a heap.[13]

Collins argues that such solutions are unsatisfactory as there seems little significance to the difference between 9,999 grains and 10,000 grains. The boundary, wherever it may be set, remains arbitrary, and so its precision is misleading. It is objectionable on both philosophical and linguistic grounds: the former on account of its arbitrariness and the latter on the ground that it is simply not how natural language is used.[14]

要求精確定義本身就已經帶有誤導性。對開放式定義的要求，就是連續體謬誤內所說的主旨